As I recall (and my memory is not as good as it used to be) when I ordered new ones for my 69, I had to send several back because the were selling ones for 67/68 as good for all three years. They will fit but the 69 is a little different. The new one you have looks like the 67/68 version. Did you get it from CI?
-=>Lee<=- Due to budget constraints the "light at the end of the tunnel" has been turned off!