Cary, I just went through the same dilemma and decided it was best to go find a decent used fender and restore that. I did quite a bit of research and it all pointed to avoiding the repops for fenders. Floorpans would be fine though. I do have two used passenger fenders, but both require some work. If you're doing the work yourself it might be worth it, but if you're paying someone you'd probably be better off finding one elsewhere. One of them was dipped and is down to bare metal. I had a shop doing mine and it was more cost effective for me to go find one in better shape rather than have them fix mine. Let me know if you're interested and I can send a couple photos.
