Wow. Now, my wife is definitely cool, and she's a tomboy, but I'll never ever hear her tell me "go build a 455 and leave the windows like they are!"
I hear what you are saying, but my house doesn't have storm windows, just single pane glass. I have had other people tell me the same thing about keeping the old glass. But, a couple of them are broken from the dogs wrestling and banging into them. Some of the frames have rot & mold too. They are in sad shape. I've talked to Shelah (my wife) about just replacing the broken glass, but she wants the new stuff. I'm beginning to agree. The new windows will be quieter, and the house (living room especially) will feel much more cozy. I planned on ordering Pella's from Lowes and putting them in myself.