John, as I mentioned in the email reply, all the 67's that I have seen in Repro look very good. The previous owner had replaced mine before I bought it and it looks and fits great!
I've heard horror stories about the 68's and especially the 69's... but have never heard any problems with the 67's? They are much easier to install and should be easier to repro?
Amervo, Just Dashes takes your original dash, and sands away almost all of the foam pad and then they reproduce the dash pad in much the same way the originals were done, in a heat mold process that forms the foam to the original metal backing.
Quite labor intensive, but again, I've heard nothing but good results... but at a price!
John, I'd got with a repro, OR, definately buy the one from Ike! That sounds like the best bet!