I used the "shelf paper" on my console because it was assembled from pieces that had faded differently. It does not match the wood on the dash exactly but looks much better than it did before. If I could find an original console for a resonable price I would switch in a minute but until then, I am happy with the way it looks. I too am amazed that by now nobody has come up with a product that matches better.
mine has 3 different shades too...the original console had dings in the operating lid and was missing the ash tray cover...I bought another lid w/o dings...its slightly better, then found a cover from a coupe! meaning its lots better...not faded...